| Platinum | Verde, Flavors of Mexico |
| Gold | Tequila Sunrise |
| Silver | Riviera Maya Mexican Cuisine |
| Bronze | El Camino Real |
| Top Pick | Agave Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Chuy's |
| Top Pick | El Lago Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | L&M Taqueria |
| Top Pick | LA Hacienda Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Samano's Mexican Food |