| Platinum | Greek's Pizzeria |
| Gold | I Tre Mori |
| Silver | Ale Emporium |
| Bronze | Hot Box Pizza |
| Bronze | Hungry Howie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Passione Wood Oven Pizza and Wings |
| Top Pick | Pizza King |
| Top Pick | Puccini's Pizza Pasta |
| Top Pick | Rockstone Pizza |
| Top Pick | Saxony Pizzeria |
| Chatham Tap |