| Platinum | Kiddie Academy of Fishers, IN |
| Gold | Alphabet Academy |
| Silver | Leafspring of Geist |
| Bronze | The Goddard School |
| Top Pick | Fishers Landing KinderCare |
| Top Pick | Leaping Leo's In-Home Childcare |
| Top Pick | Play School At Saxony Village |
| Top Pick | Primrose School at Gray Eagle |
| Top Pick | Teddy Bear Day Care |
| Top Pick | The Tot Spot Early Education Academy |